Two weeks ago we covered the full landscape of year-end tax moves. Last week we went deeper on the mechanics of each. This week is a focused treatment of the single year-end decision with the most long-term financial leverage for most retirees with pre-tax account balances: whether to do a Roth conversion, and if so, exactly how much.
This decision has a hard deadline. Roth conversions cannot be done retroactively. A conversion executed before December 31, 2026 reduces the pre-tax balance on which 2027 and future RMDs are calculated, moves that growth into a permanently tax-free environment, and potentially reduces IRMAA exposure beginning in 2028. A conversion not executed by December 31 is simply not a 2026 conversion. The opportunity does not carry forward.
The Four Questions That Determine Whether to Convert
Before sizing a conversion, four foundational questions need honest answers:
- Is today’s marginal rate lower than your expected future rate on the same income? If you are in the 22% bracket today and expect to be in the 24% or higher bracket in future years when RMDs stack on top of Social Security and pension income, converting at 22% today is permanently advantageous. If your future rate is likely to be the same or lower, the conversion math is less compelling.
- Do you have bracket room available? What is the gap between your current projected taxable income and the top of your current bracket? That number, adjusted downward for the IRMAA boundary check, is your maximum conversion capacity for 2026.
- Can you pay the conversion tax from funds outside the IRA? The most efficient conversion uses non-IRA money to pay the tax. If you have to take additional IRA distributions to cover the tax bill, the effective rate on the conversion increases and the net benefit is reduced. Pre-tax funds paying for a conversion are not going into the Roth — they are going to the IRS.
- How long is the money likely to stay in the Roth? Conversions produce their greatest benefit when converted assets compound tax-free for many years. A conversion at 65 with a 25-year runway is significantly more powerful than one at 80 with a 10-year runway. The earlier in the retirement window, the more compounding advantage the Roth receives.
The IRMAA Boundary Check — The Most Common Sizing Error
The most common year-end Roth conversion error is failing to check the conversion amount against IRMAA thresholds before executing. A conversion that fills the 22% federal bracket perfectly may simultaneously push MAGI above the first IRMAA tier — adding $70 to $140 per month per person to Medicare premiums for the following two years. At $140/month per person for a couple over 24 months, the IRMAA cost is $6,720 — potentially more than the tax rate differential the conversion was designed to capture.
The correct approach: check both constraints simultaneously. The conversion should be sized to the smaller of the bracket capacity and the IRMAA headroom — unless a specific analysis shows that crossing the IRMAA boundary is worth it because the long-term Roth benefit on the full conversion clearly outweighs the two-year premium cost.
For 2026, the first IRMAA threshold for married couples filing jointly is approximately $212,000 of MAGI. For a couple with $150,000 of combined pre-conversion income, the IRMAA headroom is approximately $62,000. If the bracket calculation yields higher conversion capacity — say, $80,000 — the IRMAA-constrained answer is $62,000, not $80,000, unless the analysis explicitly justifies crossing.
The California Component
California taxes Roth conversions as ordinary income at state rates that reach 9.3% in the middle income range and 13.3% at the top. For a couple in the 22% federal bracket in California’s 9.3% range, the combined marginal cost of a conversion is approximately 31.3%. That combined rate is still below the expected future combined rate in many scenarios — particularly for retirees with large pre-tax balances who project significant RMD income — but the advantage is narrower than it appears from the federal rate alone.
The practical implication: size your conversion against the full combined federal-plus-California rate and compare it against your expected future combined rate, not just the federal brackets. A conversion that is clearly beneficial in a state with no income tax may be marginally beneficial or neutral in California. The calculation is still worth doing — it just needs to include both tax layers to be accurate.
The Multi-Year Context: Where Does This Conversion Fit?
A single year-end conversion does not exist in isolation. It is one step in a multi-year conversion strategy designed to reduce the pre-tax balance that will generate forced RMD income beginning at age 73. The question is not just “should I convert this year?” but “how does this year’s conversion fit into the overall plan?”
If you are in the middle of a planned multi-year conversion sequence, this year’s conversion amount should be consistent with the annual amounts in that plan unless something has changed — your income was higher than projected, a life change affected your tax picture, or a market decline created an opportunity to convert more shares at lower value.
If you have not yet designed a multi-year conversion strategy, this year-end conversion is a reasonable first step and also a prompt: the November deadline creates urgency that should translate into a January planning session to design the full conversion roadmap before the window years pass without being fully used.
Executing the Conversion: Process and Timing
Once the conversion amount is confirmed, the mechanics are straightforward. Contact your IRA custodian and request a Roth conversion for the specified dollar amount. The traditional IRA will show a distribution and the Roth IRA will show a contribution. You will receive a Form 1099-R reflecting the taxable distribution and a Form 5498 confirming the Roth contribution.
For tax withholding: have the tax paid from outside the IRA, not withheld from the conversion. If 22% is withheld from a $100,000 conversion, only $78,000 reaches the Roth — $78,000 of future tax-free growth rather than $100,000. Paying the conversion tax from savings or a taxable account preserves the full converted amount in the Roth.
Practical deadline: initiate no later than December 20 to allow processing buffer. Call your custodian to confirm their specific year-end cutoff for Roth conversions — some institutions have internal deadlines earlier than December 31. Get confirmation before initiating, not after.
FAQ: What If I Convert Too Much and End Up in a Higher Bracket?
Roth conversion recharacterization — the ability to undo a completed conversion — was permanently eliminated by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act effective January 1, 2018. A conversion cannot be undone. If you convert more than intended and push income into a higher bracket, you pay the higher marginal rate on the excess. This is why precise income projection before executing is essential. If you are uncertain about any income component, build a conservative buffer below the relevant boundary rather than targeting the ceiling exactly. The cost of being $5,000 under the bracket limit is minimal — you have slightly less in the Roth this year than you could have had. The cost of being $5,000 over is the bracket differential on that amount, plus potential IRMAA consequences if you crossed a tier boundary. Err toward caution when the projection has uncertainty.
If you want to work through the specific conversion amount for your situation — your current income, bracket position, IRMAA exposure, and California tax component — this is a calculation that requires your actual numbers and is most valuable before December arrives with its compressed timeline.
Schedule a complimentary Roth conversion analysis with our office. We will run the full year-end conversion analysis for your specific situation and give you a precise, defensible conversion amount to execute before December 31.

